Thursday, October 29, 2015

Considering Types

To narrow down what my public argument will be like, I'm considering which type of public argument type will be best for me to accomplish the purpose of my argument.

stillwellmike. "Saguaro National Park, Tucson, AZ." 3/11/12 via Flickr.
Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic License.

In looking at the different types of arguments, I'm seeing that a refutation argument might be most useful.  I want to prove that the current Tucson drought plan is not comprehensive enough, and doesn't thoroughly consider the long term effects of drought.  In doing this, I would analyze the drought plan and point out the weaknesses.  Like the exercise we did in class (although we didn't get to the refutation part), I would point out the ineffective points of the current proposal that exists.

Another possibility I'm considering is a proposal argument.  Because I want the drought plan to be changed, I could go about that by proposing my own ideas of what would be effective instead.  However, I don't think that I'm experienced and knowledgeable enough to make a plan that was as comprehensive as it needs to be, since I don't know a lot about water law and policy yet (I haven't yet taken those classes).

A causal argument or a proposal argument don't seem like they would be a very helpful way for me to present and organize my argument.  The cause of why I think the current drought plan is unsuitable doesn't really matter; what matters is that it needs to be fixed.  And finding the pros and cons also doesn't really make sense either.  Lastly, an evaluative argument is the opposite of what I want to do, because I don't want to praise and support the plan, I want to change it.  Of course, that doesn't mean I want to attack the current plan totally, and I understand that even the fundamental fact we have a drought plan is important and not something that should be taken for granted.  The general idea of the plan is good.  The only problem is, it doesn't go in depth enough.  So because of this, a refutation argument would probably be most suitable for my argument.


REFLECTION

Both Austin and Chris are considering refutation arguments like me.  I think that refutation arguments might be common for this assignment, because it's easy to find things that we're not happy about to make a strong argument against.  Personally, I'm considering to lean towards refutation, but I'm wondering if I could do a mix of a refutation and a proposal.  Because although I am not experienced enough to give highly detailed advice, I do have some suggestions, and I want to be able to propose some solutions instead of just being critical.  Because I've actually talked with the mayor, and I know that they are trying to make water conservation a priority, but it might be hard to take drastic action.  I also want to acknowledge that Tucson does have the right idea, and so I don't want to be totally harsh and attacking the city council.

My Rhetorical Action Plan

I'm continuing to developing my understanding of my rhetorical situation for the public argument I will be making regarding Tucson's drought preparedness.  In doing this, I will examine my audience, the genre of my argument, and how to handle possible reactions to my argument.

Howcheng. "Catalinas and Tuscon AZ." 4/24/06 via Wikimedia Commons.
Public Domain License.

AUDIENCE

My audience is the Tucson city council.  From what I can tell reading their current drought preparedness plan, they seem to be informed somewhat about the issue, but not in deeply scientific terms, so it's important for them to gain at least somewhat of that knowledge.  As I mentioned before in my "Audience and Genre" post, local political leaders will value many things that do not have much to do with environmental issues, such as managing the local economy and preparing the city budget.

However, they still should value the water resources Tucson has, because water is a huge part of everyday life, and with a limited supply we all would be forced to function much differently.  Overall, the city council must effectively run, take care of, and improve the city, so anything that affects the city's well being becomes an interest of the city council.  However, as I discussed earlier, their priorities might not favor water issues as much as other problems.

 Because the city council must manage the city's well being, anything they will take interest in my argument.  Depending on how persuasive I am, the city council could take action and revise their plan.  In being persuasive, one of the best techniques might be to present statistics about Tucson's water consumption and reliance on the Colorado River through Central Arizona Project, and then respectively statistics about how quickly the Colorado River is shrinking.

It also might be effective to point out exactly how long the water that Tucson has stored will last, because I think it's misleading and actually will support Tucson for a very short amount of time given our current water consumption habits.  In the way of visual elements, perhaps pictures that highlight the shrinkage of Lake Mead, or show how CA is affected by the drought could be helpful.


GENRE

I'm sticking with the genres that I outlined in my "Audience and Genre" post, which include either a letter to city council, or an editorial for the newspaper.

For the editorial, I would aim to have it published in the Arizona Daily Star, since that's the local newspaper for Tucson.  An editorial would express my views while addressing the general public and city council, both of which will be affected by drought and water regulations.  Editorials are formal, but can be somewhat informal, especially when particularly impassioned.  It would probably be most helpful to use pathos and logos.  Pathos is a good way to get people to care about an issue, and making it clear that drought will have emotional impacts is important.  Logos provides powerful statistics that will prove how dire the situation is.

Editorials usually contain only text and no visual elements.  Because the issue I'm looking at is so narrow, the examples I've found are from the LA Times and therefore aren't related to Tucson specifically, but are instead about the CA drought.  You can view them here and here.

A letter sent directly to city council would be effective because it would go directly to the people that would be in charge of making the changes.  The letter would need to be formal and effectively convey that the drought plan needs to be more comprehensive and consider further long term effects and solutions.  To do this, some pathos and mostly logos appeals would be necessary.  Statistics that I mentioned earlier, such as the amount of water Tucson consumes annually or monthly, would be important to include, and stress the consequences of these numbers.

It would also be important to establish that the fact our water tables aren't dropping is less reassuring than it seems, because we're getting out water from the Colorado River, which is shrinking and therefore soon the amount of water we are allocated will be curtailed.  Perhaps a simple graph depicting these statistics would be useful, but too many visual elements could easily become overwhelming.  And again, because this topic is so narrow, the best examples I could find of letters are not related to this controversy; letters like these aren't usually published.  You can view the examples I found here and here.


RESPONSES/ACTIONS

Some positive actions I would like to see as a result of my public argument include:

  • Open dialogue about the issue; raised awareness
  • A more comprehensive drought plan
  • Water regulations put in place to help the city begin reducing its water consumption

Some negative reactions I might receive (and how I would respond to them) include:
  • Apathy -- people don't believe that drought and water shortage are a serious concern
    • Response: Water shortage is a legitimate concern and we will have to face the consequences of our overconsumption very soon -- California as example
  • Concern, but it's not a top priority
    • Response: We can't continue to push off this issue because we're going to reach the low levels of the CO River that mean we're allocated less water (that's inevitable), so if we begin thinking about how to reduce our water intake now, the change will be less abrupt, and maybe we will be able to keep our higher allocations of water for longer
  • The current drought plan is adequate and enough
    • Response: The most drastic measures the current plan propose aren't going to be enough; the beginning steps only include declaring a drought, without actually instituting any real changes.  The best way to solve this issue will happen if everyone begins making a few little changes, and the quicker we can start that, the better.

Analyzing Purpose

I've begun considering what I want to say specifically and how I want to add to the issue of Tucson's drought preparedness.  I need to figure out what the purpose of my public argument will be.  Since this is a pretty narrow issue, there's not a lot of dialogue already out there, so I have a bit of freedom in terms of what I can contribute, which is helpful.

Tucsonre. "Saguaro Sunset." 7/19/10 via Wikimedia Commons.
Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

The goal of my public argument is to get Tucson to change its drought plan to make it more comprehensive.  I've decided that I'm going to pick the audience of the Tucson city council, so I'll be addressing who would consider rewriting the current plan.  I need to prove at least that the current plan isn't suitable.  I'm still unsure as to if I could offer a clear solution, though.

The most plausible reactions to my public argument are either that 1) nothing changes, or that 2) the plan is revised.  The extent to how much the plan is revised will depend on my convincing my argument is, and how much money it might cost to spend time changing the plan.  It's not very plausible that the plan would be rewritten entirely, or be able to prepare for what might happen in 100 years, because that's not reasonable, and we don't even know what will happen in 100 years.  It is however, more plausible to change it to something that plans for what could happen more like 15 or 20 years in advance, instead of just 5 to 10, which is what the current plan seems to be capable of handling.

The effects of revising the plan could be raising more awareness of the problem, in ways such as realizing what's happening in California is a pretty accurate depiction of what could happen to Arizona in the near future.  Depending on how the plan is revised, other effects could be how Tucson allocates water, or how much water residential areas and companies are allowed to use.  The public might be required to reduce their water consumption either immediately, or sooner and perhaps more severely than was originally planned for.

I've already identified the audience I want to address.  It would be good if I could find out specifically who wrote the current drought plan, and if there is some kind of existing committee that deals with these issues.  It would be helpful to become more aware about the specific people in the city council involved, to narrow down the audience further.

Tuesday, October 27, 2015

Analyzing Context

Since I've established my audience, I'm going to explore the context of the issue in order to fully understand the rhetorical situation of my issue.  My issue is very narrow, focusing on the effectiveness of Tucson's drought preparedness, and so the perspectives related are valid, but not widely held by most people, since this issue doesn't affect the majority of the population.  Here is a link to my annotated bibliography, so you can get a better idea of the issue I'm addressing.

Georgemakar. "Green Earth Moon." 4/5/15 via Wikimedia Commons.
Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

The different perspectives involved in this issue come from the different people that are involved.  There is the political sector which must write the rules of how to handle drought, and how to interpret and work with the water laws that apply to Tucson and Arizona.  The political sphere must consider what is feasible and economically reasonable.  There are also those who are concerned with the future of Tucson's water resources, and want to see a more comprehensive drought plan written to ensure that we are prepared for the future, and not just what will happen in the next few decades.

The political sphere has different priorities than those concerned about environmental issues.  There are many different issues in Tucson these leaders must deal with, and so they are less inclined to spend as much time or thought writing a suitable drought plan.  They most likely believe that the current plan is sufficient; it at least meets the requirements that declared Tucson must have a drought plan.  People concerned about environmental issues certainly want to push the issue of water resources towards the top of the priority list, and believe that what is currently in place is inadequate.  These people are more inclined to think long term about the issue, since they don't have all the other concerns not related to the environment that the local political leaders have.

Between both groups however, there is some common ground.  Both groups acknowledge that drought is an issue that needs to be addressed.  The extent to which it needs to be addressed is where they differ.  Both groups are concerned with issues larger than themselves; the political sphere needs to serve its constituents, and the environmental sector is concerned with how humans are impacting the environment.  These groups also both need each other to work together and address the issue.  Government involvement is one of the best ways to draw attention to our nation's water shortage.  And the government needs the support of scientists to understand what's threatening in our future and what we can do about it.

Again, most of the ideological differences come down to priorities.  While there are some politicians that fundamentally  don't believe in climate change, or refuse to do anything about the issue, the local leaders of Tucson aren't like that.  They realize it's an issue that will affect the people the serve, so they want to address it.  However, there is some disconnect between how informed these leaders might be about the sustainability (or lack thereof) of Tucson's water practices.

The political sphere in Tucson hasn't asked their constituents to do anything yet about reducing water consumption, because there hasn't been an official drought declared in Tucson.  In California, new regulations have been put in place to conserve how much water is used through things like irrigation (residents are only allowed to water their lawns/wash their cars on certain days of the week).  This is because there has been a declared drought in CA.  Until that happens in Tucson, there won't be any regulations.  As for environmentalists, they urge supporters to do anything from something as simple as turning off the water when they brush their teeth, to anything that requires much more effort, such as rainwater harvesting or installing composting toilets.

Obviously I share an environment-centered perspective, because I'm very concerned about resource management (hence my major). I believe that people should be more aware of all the water they consume, and that America is consuming water faster than the natural water cycle.  I think it should be part of one's character to care about the future of the environment; the idea that Americans have the right to consume endlessly -- whether that be food, water, oil, or anything else -- is a self-righteous and privileged attitude that we need to put a stop to.

Of course, it doesn't mean that those who don't put saving the environment as their top priority are bad people.  It's important for me to understand the opposing view, because I need to understand the situation fully before I cast judgement.  However, will be fatal if we continue to put off our problems as the Colorado River shrinks, and we begin to receive significantly less water.  The ultimate danger is procrastination: we shouldn't deceive ourselves and pretend we have years and years before we must deal with these issues.  We must begin understanding the gravity of the situation today.


REFLECTION

I looked at Olivia and Grace's posts, and I noticed that all of us identified two main perspectives, which are basically pro and con.  That got me wondering if we're leaving out a group that maybe isn't as dominant but still contributes to the issue.  I realized that in terms of the issue I'm dealing with, there is also the group of citizens of Tucson who really aren't interested in the drought plan at all, probably mostly because it isn't something that's crossed their minds.  I think they could also be hindering change, simply by ignorance.  Since many people might not recognize this issue as significant, it makes the issue seem less legitimate.  However, through my argument I need to prove that the general population of Tucson needs to care about this issue too, because we all will have to live with the consequences.

Saturday, October 24, 2015

Audience and Genre

The next step is for me to understand my rhetorical situation for this project.  Here, I've brainstormed some ideas regarding audience, and come up with examples of media types that would be best for those audiences.  Since my topic is pretty narrow, the options of who the audience is are pretty limited, and revolve around local people in Tucson, who would be most interested in understanding if Tucson is adequately prepared for drought.

Ossanna, Lia. "Screenshot of online Star editorial." 10/24/15 via
http://tucson.com/news/opinion/ua-faculty-staff-pay-far-behind-market
-rate/article_26063c1e-e44b-581a-8eb5-3a956208ed45.html

The first potential audience I have is political city figures who are in charge of drafting the drought preparedness plans.  I could make a public argument indicating where their current plan is weak, and how it should be fixed.  This way I'm speaking directly to the people who are in charge of implementing the most change.  City council people have a responsibility to serve the people of their community, and I would be addressing a critical issue, so they would be interested.

The first place I could publish or present my research would be in the form of a letter to my council people in charge of the issue.  The letter would include the important points of my research distilled into language that those without a strong background would still understand.  This way I would be directly contacting the council members in a typical way most citizens communicate with their city council.  Examples of letters to city council members can be found here, here and here.

The second place I could publish my argument would be the op-ed section of the Arizona Daily Star.  Since this is a local newspaper, those reading it would be affected by the issue, and informed that I was attempting to communicate with the city council about the issue.  For an op-ed piece, I would have to explain how this issue is pertinent to all of Tucson and worth spending time thinking about.  I would have to connect the idea more closely to the general public of Tucson.  Op-ed pieces generally share firm beliefs, giving some background about the past as well as describing what the current situation is.  Op-ed pieces address less of how to solve a problem, and instead are used to bring awareness about an issue.  Examples of op-ed pieces from the Star can be found here and here (note that I don't endorse the beliefs presented in this article).

As for the second potential audience, I could focus on engaging the local academic community that would be interested about the environmental effects and conservation strategies currently in place.  These people would most likely consist of professors in the hydrology department at the U of A.

In talking to these UA professors, I could go about talking the issue in a different way and present the information in a video format, with narration and shots of relevant parts, like Tucson Water or the Tucson Aqueduct.  The purpose of the video would be to prove that drought preparedness is an important issue to focus on.  This video could then be used to inform the public about the issue.  National Geographic makes videos like this; examples can be found here and here.  However, this it is unlikely I will execute this idea, because I have little skill in making videos or animation, and prefer writing.

Another way I could communicate with the academic sphere is by a short research proposal.  This wouldn't be as extensive as normal research proposals, but would rather focus on stating the issue at hand, some background knowledge, and then ask for help from these professors to expand this idea into an actual research proposal and plan.  I won't have enough information to actually compose the research plan myself, and that's not really a public argument, but instead I could sort of write a proposal to a research proposal.  Examples of short research proposals can be found here and here.

As an end note, I was trying to be more creative with my last two ideas regarding my second audience, but in reality those ideas will probably be more difficult to execute, and might not come across as clear public arguments.  The two ideas I had before for the first audience are probably what I will begin exploring.

Friday, October 23, 2015

Project 3 Annotated Bibliography

Now that I've come up with some specific research questions for Project 3, I've looked at some sources to gather the information.  I've complied an annotated bibliography to organize my research, which can be viewed here.

Tfinc. "Citation needed stickers." 2/26/13 via Wikimedia Commons.
Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

My sources will probably look different than most people's, because I took information from government resources and legal papers rather than general sources.  Because I'm looking at specifically Tucson, the area is too small and the issue hasn't received enough attention to generate any kind of useful information via general sources.  However, I'm choosing to do this project about Tucson, because I want to know about the water rights and plan for the city that I live in.  I found how to specifically cite government documents from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Narrowing My Focus

Since I collected a variety of questions, I need to narrow down my focus to something manageable and specific.  Overall the topic I will be looking at is how Arizona has prepared for drought.  The main question is, What steps have been taken to prepare for water shortages in Arizona (specifically Tucson)?  To answer this question, I'm going to have to answer a few more questions that I came up with in the last post.

XcepticZP. "Arizona cap canal." 3/25/08 via
Wikimedia Commons. Public Domain License.

The first question is What are the water rights concerning the Colorado River and other major water resources for Arizona?

I know from my basic knowledge about water rights in the western part of the US, it's based on seniority.  Arizona doesn't have high seniority, so we will be one of the first states to lose water rights, and therefore our water source will be greatly reduced.  Understanding this in deeper detail is important for knowing how lowering water levels will affect Arizona, and will explain the need for Arizona to have backup plan.

The second question is How has this issue been discussed in the political realm?

It's really important to understand how how the political sphere has prepared for water shortages, because they have jurisdiction of the water.  I need to investigate how local political figures such as the mayor and city council people are passing regulations that relate to water shortages.  I know that Tucson has some water stored, but I don't know how long that will last, and I don't know how far in advance the local government has planned for.